Faults and Complaints of RFL

Calloway wrote:

Ghost wrote:

Shaps wrote:That would be impossible to spot as a ref I'd think. And if they do what? Give them a penalty? Doesn't really work

1 minute 5v4 powerplay!

This isn't Ice Hockey...

Ghost wrote:

Calloway wrote:

Ghost wrote:

Shaps wrote:That would be impossible to spot as a ref I'd think. And if they do what? Give them a penalty? Doesn't really work

1 minute 5v4 powerplay!

This isn't Ice Hockey...

Didn't say it was.

However, without the ability to give free kicks or penalties without switching the map, maybe looking to a sport like ice hockey(that is actually more similar to haxball than football is) for a little inspiration on enforcing rules would be a wise thing to do.

That is unless you prefer playing/watching 0-0 busball for most of your night of course.


The 3 man rule in 4v4 games has become such common knowledge now that it is hardly ever breached. It wouldn't take long for a 4-man rule in 5v5 to become a normal thing.

<º)))< wrote:It's needed a rule that hardly punish impersonations as long as we have wildcards and loans as options.

Imo:

It's the cap's duty to ensure that the right players are in the match, and not impersonators.

So, if an impersonation occurs and can be proven, point deduction to the team + defwin for the other team (or keeping the result of the match if its bigger than the defloss) and banning for all the season for the player who impersonated others.

Shaps wrote: • Teams will play each other once (11 games)

Shaps wrote:• Substitutions may only be made at Goal Kicks and Corner Kicks. The captain of the team must call sub in the chat for a sub to occur. If a player unexpectedly leaves the team must wait until it has gone for a Goal Kick or Corner Kick before replacing them. There is no limit on the amount of subs to be made during the match

Shaps wrote:• Substitutions may only be made at Goal Kicks and Corner Kicks. The captain of the team must call sub in the chat for a sub to occur. If a player unexpectedly leaves the team must wait until it has gone for a Goal Kick or Corner Kick before replacing them. There is no limit on the amount of subs to be made during the match

Kosc ʕ·͡ᴥ·ʔ wrote:
I personally disagree with the rule that subs should only be made at corner kicks and goal kicks. In my opinion, there should be no reason why subs cannot be made at throw-ins. On numerous occasions I have seen a player waiting a good few minutes to get subbed on.

Ghost wrote:

Calloway wrote:

Ghost wrote:

Shaps wrote:That would be impossible to spot as a ref I'd think. And if they do what? Give them a penalty? Doesn't really work

1 minute 5v4 powerplay!

This isn't Ice Hockey...

Didn't say it was.

However, without the ability to give free kicks or penalties without switching the map, maybe looking to a sport like ice hockey(that is actually more similar to haxball than football is) for a little inspiration on enforcing rules would be a wise thing to do.

That is unless you prefer playing/watching 0-0 busball for most of your night of course.


The 3 man rule in 4v4 games has become such common knowledge now that it is hardly ever breached. It wouldn't take long for a 4-man rule in 5v5 to become a normal thing.

opc wrote:

Ghost wrote:

Calloway wrote:

Ghost wrote:

Shaps wrote:That would be impossible to spot as a ref I'd think. And if they do what? Give them a penalty? Doesn't really work

1 minute 5v4 powerplay!

This isn't Ice Hockey...

Didn't say it was.

However, without the ability to give free kicks or penalties without switching the map, maybe looking to a sport like ice hockey(that is actually more similar to haxball than football is) for a little inspiration on enforcing rules would be a wise thing to do.

That is unless you prefer playing/watching 0-0 busball for most of your night of course.


The 3 man rule in 4v4 games has become such common knowledge now that it is hardly ever breached. It wouldn't take long for a 4-man rule in 5v5 to become a normal thing.

I think the 5v4 powerplay, or 1 minute sin bin if you prefer a slightly less American name, should be looked at. It's an easy way to punish the breach of a rule. Maybe a warning after the first breach and then sin bin if the rule is breached again.

Apple wrote:My Personal Faults of Hax RFL

1) Admins have too much to say - I know that Admins are meant to be the ones that look after people on chatbox and supposed to be the most 'responsible' but its not like that in this league, Often when people have some good ideas or some things that are wrong and should be discussed I feel as if they are ignored just because they think that they are the ones that are the most 'important' in the community. (not pointing any fingers out)

We do kinda run the league, give us some credit.

2) 1 team = 1 admin - There are teams with a lot of admins, but ones without even 1. I personally think that a team should have at least 1 admin so the teams that currently have no admins in them, have the same right and say as any other team because i would think that often, the teams with more admins get their own way because of the power that they think they have.

Nice try trying to get admin, no.

3) Admins can access other teams private forums - Some teams don't even have any things written down in their private forums because of the thought that admins could see whats inside them. Now, As far as i know, Private Forums mean that they are not accessible for any other members than the ones that belong to the usergroup. Not going to lie here, I never knew about this and i write a lot of stuff in the private forums such as lineups and different tactics for each game and now that i think about it, Some admin can come in and copy it and then paste it to their own private forum taking credit as if they made it their self.

Nothing you can do about that, you can't set forums with permissions that admins cannot have read access, sry.

4) Ban Samuel/Mourinho/Luiz - I really don't know why he is still here. He makes my RFL experience less fun and he should be banned for a lot of things such as multi accounting, Is he some kind of special person that can do whatever he wants wherever he wants? Rules are not there to break and he just proves that they are. I know if i did some things that he does such as spamming emoticons on the chatbox i would be banned ages ago.

Yes.

5) Rules not written down in Rulebook shouldn't count - < Clearly says what I mean, Something happens and suddenly admin appears and say some kind of rule that is not even present in the rulebook. No rule in the Rulebook = No rule.

Do you want to write a 20 page rulebook, because I don't. You can't plan for every eventuality, its a haxball league for god sake.

Apple wrote:Mlfaijati if you would learn to read more carefully, Up there it says ''My Personal faults of Hax RFL''. lol at people who think i wrote 1 team - 1 admin and think that i want admin, If you would ask me if i want it i wouldn't because it changes people.

Apple wrote:My Personal Faults of Hax RFL

1) Admins have too much to say - I know that Admins are meant to be the ones that look after people on chatbox and supposed to be the most 'responsible' but its not like that in this league, Often when people have some good ideas or some things that are wrong and should be discussed I feel as if they are ignored just because they think that they are the ones that are the most 'important' in the community. (not pointing any fingers out)

2) 1 team = 1 admin - There are teams with a lot of admins, but ones without even 1. I personally think that a team should have at least 1 admin so the teams that currently have no admins in them, have the same right and say as any other team because i would think that often, the teams with more admins get their own way because of the power that they think they have.

3) Admins can access other teams private forums - Some teams don't even have any things written down in their private forums because of the thought that admins could see whats inside them. Now, As far as i know, Private Forums mean that they are not accessible for any other members than the ones that belong to the usergroup. Not going to lie here, I never knew about this and i write a lot of stuff in the private forums such as lineups and different tactics for each game and now that i think about it, Some admin can come in and copy it and then paste it to their own private forum taking credit as if they made it their self.

4) Ban Samuel/Mourinho/Luiz - I really don't know why he is still here. He makes my RFL experience less fun and he should be banned for a lot of things such as multi accounting, Is he some kind of special person that can do whatever he wants wherever he wants? Rules are not there to break and he just proves that they are. I know if i did some things that he does such as spamming emoticons on the chatbox i would be banned ages ago.

5) Rules not written down in Rulebook shouldn't count - < Clearly says what I mean, Something happens and suddenly admin appears and say some kind of rule that is not even present in the rulebook. No rule in the Rulebook = No rule.

mlfaijati wrote:

Apple wrote:My Personal Faults of Hax RFL

1) Admins have too much to say - I know that Admins are meant to be the ones that look after people on chatbox and supposed to be the most 'responsible' but its not like that in this league, Often when people have some good ideas or some things that are wrong and should be discussed I feel as if they are ignored just because they think that they are the ones that are the most 'important' in the community. (not pointing any fingers out)

We do kinda run the league, give us some credit.

Doesn't seem as if you are running the league, don't get me wrong, i don't know what happens in the admin meetings but you are barely on the chat.

2) 1 team = 1 admin - There are teams with a lot of admins, but ones without even 1. I personally think that a team should have at least 1 admin so the teams that currently have no admins in them, have the same right and say as any other team because i would think that often, the teams with more admins get their own way because of the power that they think they have.

Nice try trying to get admin, no.

I don't even want admin, my point is to make teams more even because when 1 team has 2 admins in the team and some have none it is a bit unfair when it comes to some decision that happens in the match and the team that has more admins will have a bigger say because they have admins.

3) Admins can access other teams private forums - Some teams don't even have any things written down in their private forums because of the thought that admins could see whats inside them. Now, As far as i know, Private Forums mean that they are not accessible for any other members than the ones that belong to the usergroup. Not going to lie here, I never knew about this and i write a lot of stuff in the private forums such as lineups and different tactics for each game and now that i think about it, Some admin can come in and copy it and then paste it to their own private forum taking credit as if they made it their self.

Nothing you can do about that, you can't set forums with permissions that admins cannot have read access, sry.

Then tell me whats the purpose of private forums when admins can access them whenever they want without captains knowing it?

4) Ban Samuel/Mourinho/Luiz - I really don't know why he is still here. He makes my RFL experience less fun and he should be banned for a lot of things such as multi accounting, Is he some kind of special person that can do whatever he wants wherever he wants? Rules are not there to break and he just proves that they are. I know if i did some things that he does such as spamming emoticons on the chatbox i would be banned ages ago.

Yes.

Why is he still on the forum not banned?

5) Rules not written down in Rulebook shouldn't count - < Clearly says what I mean, Something happens and suddenly admin appears and say some kind of rule that is not even present in the rulebook. No rule in the Rulebook = No rule.

Do you want to write a 20 page rulebook, because I don't. You can't plan for every eventuality, its a haxball league for god sake.

20 page rulebook for a haxball league is a bit too much don't you think? as long as admins make sure to write them down after an accident happened its fine.